8.5' x 40' Wide Clear Span Modular BoxBlind

in Architectural Design held by Brad Willem
Contest Ended, Winner(s) have been selected.
  • Open
  • Choosing Finalist
  • Ended
Description:
Looking for visual representation of an idea for 8.5' wide modular construction for single and multifamily applications.

The idea is to create 8.5' W x 40' L (Max) modular "boxes" that stack upon one another and connect at floor and ceiling allowing smooth ceilings and transitions (no bulk heads or furr downs at ceiling transitions). The idea being at 8.5' max span the loads will be minimal and allow for up to 40' (?) clear spans on non exterior walls.

The floor systems would need to be of floor truss construction with a 9-1/4" depth, with the 1st floor being a flat type (or bottom mount) with the 2nd floor being a flat type on exterior walls and top chord mount on clear span side. Sub floor will be 3/4" T&G. The exterior walls would be 2x4 or 2x6 studs at 9' height finished on the outside with 7/16 osb and 1/2" drywall on the inside. The ceilings would be 2x4 or 2x6" joist with a layer of 7/16" and drywall on bottom chord that would be mounted on the double top plate of the exterior wall and flush mounted w/ metal hangers on a 3.5" x 11-7/8" glu-lam or LVL (2-ply 1.75"). The LVL or glu-lam would run the length of the "box" (max 40') and would support the 2nd story floor truss on the top mounted side.

Deliverable:

I need a visual representation of the above, one each of the four of the types of "boxes" as noted (one 1st floor with 3 exteriors walls, one 2nd floor with 3 exteriors walls, one 1st floor with only end walls and one 2nd floor with only end walls, all finished as noted (drywall, osb etc.). 3D would be preferable, but 2D would work as well. This is a tool to share with designers and engineers to create a proof of concept, what I am needing at this current time is just the concept in digital form.
Wants:
The chosen design would be the one who's digital interpretation most closely represents the described project and which is most useful to help share the idea with others in concept form
Don't Wants:
I do not need anything overly stylized nor decorated. Just a simple representation of the description.

Entries

= Buyer's Rating
1st Winner
#1 First sketch by Jim81
Feb 7, 2018 23:51
#2 2nd sketch by Jim81
Feb 8, 2018 14:51
#3 Sketch by Jim81
Feb 8, 2018 15:24
#4 Sketch # 4 by Jim81
Feb 8, 2018 17:50
#5 Sketch # 5 by Jim81
Feb 9, 2018 16:43
#6 SKETCH # 5 by Jim81
Feb 9, 2018 20:57
#7 sketch # 7 by Jim81
Feb 9, 2018 23:58
#9 8.5' x 40' Wide Clear Span Modular Box by Mahbub
Feb 12, 2018 17:14
#10 Modular house plan by Jim81
Feb 14, 2018 23:18
#11 modular box truss fram by Jim81
Feb 15, 2018 1:14

Discussion

Fri, 16 Feb 2018 22:33:23 +0000
I have designed loads of this type of mod buildings
two three storeys no problem the struct uses continual columns to bear the weight
I worked at a place called willerby holiday homes in the uk

arkiattack

Designer

Wed, 14 Feb 2018 04:06:36 +0000
hELLo!?:O

Jim81

Designer

Fri, 09 Feb 2018 22:21:54 +0000
Brad, I agree there are some glitches that need to be worked on (like how to put the first floor ceiling onto the second floor box smoothly), I will work on it some more. The way I am stacking your modules is the way it should be done and the beam drop down is the locking joint and key to it's functionality. There will be no beam drop down every 8' as you think presently. It is designed to have a smooth ceiling throughout the entire assembled structure as you want. You could build a model off my drawings and improve on it if you can. Like you said, we are looking for concept and I know mine works. The beam pockets are solid wood studs supporting the beam end. I could draw it for you but we are getting beyond concept already. Your idea of building modular boxes is great and I commend you. I am trying and will figure it out without all the gaps in your design. Design is my field of experience. This is a fun job and I am enjoying the challenges !!

Brad Willem

Buyer

Fri, 09 Feb 2018 20:13:49 +0000
Jim,

Sorry for being out of pocket yesterday. I love the drawings, but we are still apart on the concept a bit. Here is a quick list of where we're off:

1. The ceiling of each box will need to be installed and drywall hung, in the factory. From the drawings it looks like you have the ceiling attached on the bottom of the floor of the upper box.

2. Due to above, in my mind the glulam beam will need to be part of the lower box and serve as the termination point for the ceiling to be hung with joist hangers. The beam would bear on the short exterior walls, with adequate support. The box would be constructed with wall panels, then the beam would be placed, and the ceiling (w/ drywall) would be dropped like a cap on to the box in the factory. The hangers holding the ceiling cap would install on the face of the beam and flush at the bottom so the drywall ceiling will be flat and continuous to the beam. Once installed in the field, the beam would be bare, as would the beam next to it and the joint would be covered and finished once all boxes are set. So the boxes in profile view would be a box with a rectangle protruding beyond the the top on one side or both depending if the box is an exterior unit or exterior. Your sketch 4 and 5 show a notch in the wall of the lower box and this is actually the opposite of what I had in mind as this would mean the beam would be dropped and there would be a beam protruding down from the ceiling every 8' feet or so and that would be terribly unsightly.

3. Because of , the beam is protruding beyond the top plane of the lower box, the floor joist for the upper box would need to be a floor truss with a top mount flange (I tried to portray in my scribbling I attached to the original request for design. The connection of the floor joist with the lower box on the exterior long wall is actually more concerning as I haven't quite worked that one out, but there is more opportunity to work out the details at a later point in time. I do agree a TJI would be more economical (perhaps not as the floor truss could be produced in the same factory as the wall panels, but I digress), however it would a difficult exercise to crane the upper box in place in the field and try to get everything to align into joist hangers.

Other than those items, the idea is on track, we are just seeing the beam placement differently. For me, the ceiling being flat across the entire plain, no matter how many boxes are used per story, is the essence of this project as this would over come some of the issues in appearance between current 16' wide modular box designs and site built homes. The idea of using "the beam" is to keep the interior design possibilities as numerous as possible to help bridge the gap in home buyers perceptions when comparing modular type construction versus traditional site built homes as ultimately this is the biggest hurdle in this whole en devour and the regulatory issues, but that is a whole different conversation for a different time.

Again, I can't tell you enough how much I appreciate your input so far.

Thanks,

Brad

Jim81

Designer

Fri, 09 Feb 2018 05:00:18 +0000
Brad, center sections coming tomorrow, thanks...

Brad Willem

Buyer

Wed, 07 Feb 2018 20:26:57 +0000
Jim,

Thank you for your interest in my project, your insight is most welcomed. The method to my madness is to find an alternative to the modus operandi of the current home building industry, which I am a part of professionally. Rising costs, labor shortages, etc. are quickly diving the home building industry off of a cliff. The idea here is that some form of modular will be the answer, but not in it's current form, I don't think. The size I am looking for is the max sizing +/- for a load to be shipped over the road with out special permits and/or license and can be hauled with a heavy duty truck as opposed to semi's. I have attached a second file to the listing showing the max dimensions (ignore the roof in the drawing as it's not exactly what I have in mind). Therefore, height is paramount and I think with a 9-1/4" floor system, 9' walls and a 11-7/8" beam of some sort on top of a low deck trailer of 32" would keep the box right at the max 13-4".

Thanks again for your interest and assistance, and I look forward to your sketch.

Jim81

Designer

Wed, 07 Feb 2018 19:23:54 +0000
Sir, I am submitting a sketch that I believe is along the lines of what you seek. If you want more clarification, please let me know and I can add more info.
I am hoping that a 1/4" steel flitch plate (2-required) between each (3 LVL's) 1 3/4" x 11 7/8 glue lam will do the trick but I'll leave that to the engineers to determine.
I also believe that a ledger plate or metal joist hangers will be adequate joist hangers off the beam. There may be some advantage to having a deeper (taller) beam so that you may have space for ducts and pipes to hide. Taller LVL's will require fewer LVL's as well and may not need the steel flitch plates per my recommendations. I can draw the details as we progress with your needs. The stud walls that support the beam will have beam pockets built into the end walls. I would stay away from steel I beams because the codes would require you support the beams at each end with steel columns ! Fun Job !!

Brad Willem

Buyer

Tue, 06 Feb 2018 03:21:46 +0000
Jim,

You are correct, an LVL isn't going to work with out breaking the span. More than likely steel or a wide Glulam, if anything will work. I am looking for a visual representation of the idea so I can share with Engineers and Designers and work out the details.

This is an attempt to work out an idea and drawing is not a skill I possess, so I am looking for help on here. With that, I intend to work out the engineering if the idea can hold any weight, pun intended. Thanks for you comment.

Jim81

Designer

Mon, 05 Feb 2018 23:09:39 +0000
I'm not an engineer but I doubt a 3.5x11.75" LVL will span 40" in a floor situation. I doubt it would span any opening with a load placed on it. Is it your idea to build a three sided building 8.5 feet wide x 40 feet long, two story's high ? Where does the 12" I beam come into play ? Your drawings look like you plan for the buildings to be placed open side to open side as well as two story. Is that correct ? Double wide trailers are built similar except they don't build them two story high and never any open sides that span more than about 16 feet. This project needs an engineer badly, or allow the truss joist manufacture design the opening requirements through their facilities. If you buy the product from them the engineering is free..

Similar Contests on Cad Crowd

Residential Property
Implement a 3D design of my residential house plans including interior and exterior features.
Design our Preschool!
We are building a cool new Preschool, based on the idea of an Exploratorium/Preschool hybrid experience with a genetic learning arcade. Portably 4-6 classrooms. Need to meet current state and san francisco city standards. Looking for 60+ students, the more we can accommodate with mindful design to mitigate crowding, the better. This is a chance to build something really cool.
Home Expansion/Addition
Would like to expand kitchen, add large great room with high ceilings possibly vaulted, with back porch and grilling area, and pool. Would like back porch to span across entire back of the house over looking the pool area. Pool should be screened in.
New House Floorplan
We are seeking a 2d floorplan for a new house. Your design response should consider: 1. The attached brief 2. The attached site plan (pdf and dwg) If the brief is unclear or incomplete, please let me know and I will adjust it or provide clarity. There is flexibility to move some elements between rooms - so if you have have suggestions or recommended changes, please let me know. The design should provide a floorplan for the house and landscaped areas. You can use any software you wish. However, designs must be provided to scale in PDF format such that they can be printed on A3 paper. The scale must be shown on the drawing.
Shop Drawings AW12-079
Require Millwork Shop drawings for the reception desk only at this time. Details required to complete other areas. Other areas an extra and not part of this contest.