Small Lakefront Cottage RenovationBlind

in Architectural Design held by Benjamin Kern
Contest Ended, Winner(s) have been selected.
Description:
The attached Sketchup file is a scanned model of a 110+ year-old cottage in the woods on the shore of Lake Michigan. This is a very small house – approximately 984 square feet. A large part of the house is taken by the screened-in front porch that faces the lake.
We are limited as to the changes we can make – for example, we cannot change the footprint. We would like to change the roofline, most likely to a “t-gable” roof, given the T-shape or L-shape of the footprint), and replace the kitchen and bath with updated and more useable spaces. We would like two bedrooms and one bath (1.5 if there were any way to do so).
A similar cottage nearby has some loft space above a porch that the kids enjoy. Most of these places are open to the rafters, but ideally with bedrooms closed off.
We would like to carve out room for a washer/ dryer station (vertical).
Also love the idea of a two-sided fireplace in the main room and porch, although this may not be feasible: www.supremem.com/duet4seasons.php
This is a seasonal place and is not currently insulated. Plumbing generally runs in a crawlspace. Hot water is currently provided by a tankless electric heater. Other cottages in the area have hot water heaters below the units in the crawlspaces.
It is not critical that all the current porch space be retained.
Please note that the scan is largely accurate.
Wants:
Revisions to the attached sketchup file that are detailed enough to be used as the basis for a construction plan (and could be submitted for permitting) would be much appreciated.

We are primarily looking for a design that makes efficient use of a small space, and rationalizes a structure that was cobbled together by DIY handypeople over the course of a century.
Don't Wants:
Designs that would require changes to the footprint.

Designs that would require materials that are particularly cumbersome, given that reaching the property presents some challenges.
Ask for Sample:
Samples (rough floorplan without details) could be helpful.
Software:
  1. Trimble SketchUp (Google) (2017)

Entries

1st Winner
#27 Cottag_lake_model by Sergiu.Nasta
Mar 13, 2018 19:11
2nd Winner
#19 LAKESIDE UPDATED 3-2-18 North side porch addition by Jim81
SEE ALSO ALT. # 1 AND #2 FLOOR PLANS
more
Mar 2, 2018 17:29
#14 Lakeside total re-vamp as requested by Jim81
see also alternate # 1 and Two for bedroom wing alternates
more
Feb 25, 2018 20:01
#26 Cottag_lake_model by Sergiu.Nasta
Mar 13, 2018 19:10
#24 Michigan Cottage Remodel by KEVE
As discussed per our messages; this update removes the 2nd floor deck on both floor plans. Also, I added different roof options for both floor plans. Thank you.
more
Mar 9, 2018 15:50
#23 Lakefront Cottage Renovation by KRING ARCHITECTURE
I've changed the design at some points in order to meet your expectations.
more
Mar 8, 2018 16:22
#22 Floor plan by KRING ARCHITECTURE
First sketch floor plan
more
Mar 7, 2018 21:41
#21 Michigan Cottage Remodel by KEVE
There are two options to look at. Changed things around after our emails. Thank you.
more
Mar 6, 2018 1:59
#20 revamp #2 with existing north wing shown by Jim81
This is a re-submit of submittal #7 that was sent incorrectly.
The plan #2 has changed since this submittal, refer to 3-2-18 submittal for current plan. The existing north wing plan is as shown.
more
Mar 3, 2018 20:21
#18 lakeside north porch elev. by Jim81
Lakeside update 3-2-18
more
Mar 2, 2018 15:55
#17 NORTH ELEVATION by Jim81
NORTH ELEVATION WITH NEW PORCH ENTRANCE. Locate stairs in most desirable location. This allows the offset wall to be adjusted to accommodate the tub in the bath area. outside storage space is available under the porch. See alternate floor plans layouts.
more
Mar 1, 2018 22:08
#16 Lakeside total re-vamp as requested by Jim81
This is the plan that has been revamped to your specifications. Alternates # 1 and 2 have been submitted for the bedroom wing for your consideration prior. If your not getting them, let me know.
more
Mar 1, 2018 16:37
#15 Lakeside total re-vamp as requested by Jim81
see also alt # 1
more
Mar 1, 2018 16:27
#1 The cottage by Arhitecto
The cottage with requested additions
more
Feb 11, 2018 11:58
#11 Cottage Renovation by Mahbub
Feb 14, 2018 10:14
#10 Lake side cabin alternates 1 & 2 by Jim81
as shown
more
Feb 13, 2018 23:08
#9 Lake side cabin alternates 1 & 2 by Jim81
Good luck on your decisions !
more
Feb 13, 2018 22:52
#8 RED LINE PROPOSAL by Jim81
The red line proposal is based on your recent communication about your concerns. I hope this solution is in line with what you like. I will go forward to a final plan when the contest ends IF I am selected as the winner of the contest.
more
Feb 13, 2018 17:49
#7 rE-VAMP # 2 by Jim81
THIS IS WITH THE NORTH WALL OFFSET WHICH DOES SHOW IN A PICTURE. NOT SURE OF THE DIMENSION BUT NOT VERY IMPORTANT. IT DOES AFFECT THE BATH AND HAD TO SWITCH TO A SHOWER WITH SEAT..
more
Feb 12, 2018 22:59
#6 REVISED LAKE SIDE CABIN 783 S.F. SUBMITTAL by Jim81
SMALLER FOOTAGE LOST THE HALF BATH BUT NOT THE TRAFFIC FLOW, OPENNESSS AND FUNCTIONALITY.
I CHANGED THE LAYOUT (LIVING, DINING, KITCHEN) TO SUIT THE VIEWS BETTER FOR YOUR LOT.
more
Feb 12, 2018 18:39
#5 existing cabin plan by Jim81
This is what I was able to capture from sketch up 3-D viewer.
I had to guesstamate the dimensions but the sq. footage is very close.
Dimensions need to be verified. Best I can do with my set up presently but good enough to work with for now...
more
Feb 12, 2018 4:12
#4 Lake side cabin el # 1 & 2 by Jim81
I had to hand alter views of the new elevation. It's for your examination and approval
more
Feb 12, 2018 3:54
#3 Lake side cabin RE-VAMP plan by Jim81
This is my proposal for the re-vamping of existing cabin. I aligned the left side wall on this plan if that is the wall you spoke of. The existing foot print dimensions will have to be verified since there were no dimensions on the sketch up drawings !
The main roof gable will be extended to the left on this plan to create a loft over the bedroom with a front gable and rear gable to form the T The porch roof will be rebuilt to shed the water. No flat roofs will exist and the exterior will be updated nicely if you approve of the plan.
more
Feb 12, 2018 1:27
#2 Lake side cabin by Jim81
This is a blank floor plan based on your description of the house, the sq. footage and the front elevation picture you sent to cad crowd. Please use this as a starting point for a floor plan sketch while verifying my foot print dimensions. I'm not sure if the house is T shape or L shape from your description so I drew it as a T shape for now.
I would appreciate any input you can give so that I can move forward with a design. Thank you !
more
Feb 11, 2018 17:39

Discussion

Tue, 13 Mar 2018 21:46:02 +0000
Why submissions after contest ending Segiu Nasta ?
Tue, 06 Mar 2018 16:14:20 +0000
I have additionally uploaded a 2015 version of the sketchup file as well as some images of the existing structure. Thanks!
Sat, 03 Mar 2018 07:30:58 +0000
Hi! can u submit the file in older version please! for sketchUp 2015!?:)

Jim81

Designer

Sun, 11 Feb 2018 19:04:05 +0000
Please disregard all of my comments on this project. My Sketch up program is malfunctioning. I will get back with you when the problem is solved.
Thanks for your patience..

Jim81

Designer

Sun, 11 Feb 2018 02:17:14 +0000
Mr. Kern, I was finally able to upload your ketchup site to my computer. The only thing that shows up is an elevation of the cottage you speak of. I will need foot print dimensions of the exterior walls and at least a sketch of the existing floor plan before I can draw a preliminary design layout. If you can provide this I can move forward with you on what sounds like a fun project for us both.
Thu, 08 Feb 2018 19:02:40 +0000
Apologies - I have additionally uploaded this as an uncompressed Sketchup file. Thanks!

Jim81

Designer

Thu, 08 Feb 2018 18:49:49 +0000
Sir, the attachment opens as a Win Zip renewal add. Can yo furnish an attachment that will show your project ? Thank You

Similar Contests on Cad Crowd

Knife and Vanishing Edge Pool
Hi, I would like to build knife and vanishing edge pool in my villa under construction. The villa location is in Saudi Arabia. The pool sizi is roughly 8 meter by 4 meter. I would like a design , 3d model and rendering is and construction and puping drawings for the pool. Please let me know if you are interested to do the design and provide a budgetary quotation. I can send autocad drawing showing tentative location of the pool.
Student room
We have a Students room here. It is completly drawn till one element wich still needs to be redraw. We have a picture of it, but we are not satified with this design, so we need here your creation here. The Project shoul be finished by 01.04.2014
Home Elevations
Hello I have a floor plan for a house for my client in Texas. that i need some concepts drawn up for the exterior elevations and roof design in dwg format. I am open to Ideas that any architects have to add to the design. Traditional / colonial design would be great, a few guide lines: 11ft to 18ft plus Ceiling height. Single story house on a corner lot. Entry foyer facing corner with circular driveway. concrete slab Wood framing construction mix of stone and stucco Please do not hesitate to ask any questions. thanks
House facade design within 7 days
We are currently in the process of finalizing the design for a modern villa in the DACH (Germany/Austria/Switzerland) region. We are super happy with the front of the villa. We love the design there. However, we are not happy with the backside facade of the villa. The design misses a clear structure. There is some design element here and there. Windows are a bit randomly positioned from an outside perspective (from the inside it makes sense). So far there is no real light concept for the backside. The idea of the contest is to find our dream design for the backside of our villa. Let me provide some details. There is more in the presentation As can be seen from the floor plan we are planning the stairs with two skybridges (which means there is some space between floor and window) at the right side of the left part of the building. The idea was to have one big window that covers at least two floors. Currently the third floor which is the „Cube“ on the roof is slighthly moved back. We have also planned a small water area in front of the left part of the house so that there is a mini bridge leading to the entrance door (similar to the design of another villa we included in the presentation). There is a stairs going down to the basement where we have on the left a guest room and on the right the living/bed room of the nanny’s flat. Above that is the window to an office with library. The closed space left of it is a wall in the living room which could potentially also become a window. Above that the three windows are kids room / bathroom windows At the top in the cube the three windows are in the bathroom Now so far we have refrained from adding more windows since on the first floor we have on the left the walk-in dressing room where windows are not needed .Then at the top in the cube to the right there is far right the sauna and next to it we need the wall for some fitness device installations inside. Having said that there is always an option to have kind of fake windows where behind them there is a wall. The outcome of the competition should be some illustrations with ideas for the backside of the house also showing or highlighting some materials to be used. In addition some idea with regards to the construction leading to the basement would be welcome. How would that look best in terms of stairs, green area etc. Since we need to finalize the renderings soon, there is only a week time before ending the competition. All details an be found in the presentation including all floor plans. Please feel free to be creative. However the shape oft he building is a given.
1200 sqft apartment
I need a good design for a 1200 sqft apartment. The apartment must have 2 bedrooms with ensuite or shared bath, a guest bath ie sink & toilet, laundry area/room, kitchen, dining area, living room, clothes closets etc. Any and all ideas welcome. Top two designs win. See attached file for space. Note put in windows wherever you like except where noted. This is a second floor and stairs must remain as in the attached drawing.