#23 Finger Gap for Phone - 1st Version by Andika Jamaluddin
There are Two parts of design as you need and requested... Thanks
2016-06-02 08:22:56
#27 Finger Gap for Phone - 2nd Version by Andika Jamaluddin
This is 2nd version of my design, i was redrawing and following past issued for 1st version.
please give us feedback if there are those who do not matching the criteria.
Warm Regards !
2016-06-14 05:48:17




Tue, 14 Jun 2016 13:07:29 +0000
Sorry about the image in there. It looks like the platform shows images of the entries if you use a numeric digit in the comments.

Just disregard that image. Thanks!



Tue, 14 Jun 2016 13:06:25 +0000
Hi Andinka, Thanks for the new entry!

Unfortunately, I think this one takes a step backwards.

Primarily, You did not address from my initial concern, you made that design element actually more of an issue than before.

Also, there isn't much detail in the rendering for me to clearly see some of the nuances in the design, like the detail in the base and how it curves/interacts with the band.

Thanks again for the submission.
Fri, 03 Jun 2016 01:31:48 +0000
i'm very glad to heard about that.
Thanks for the respond my design, I will repair and submit immediately with following issues.




Thu, 02 Jun 2016 13:57:51 +0000
Thanks Andinka! Appreciate you participating in my contest!

While the design is interesting, I see the following issues with it:

1. The base looks different than our existing one, and it's not quite clear of whether or not the base has a plano-concave like design

2. The band ends, where they attach to the outer circle around the perimeter, are not flush. Meaning, if you placed this assembly on the back of a phone and laid the phone on it's back, it would be uneven do to the protruding ends

3. I can visualize how the top part of the band will stretch, do to the design, but I'm not sure if the open design lends itself to being comfortable on the finger. Meaning, if the person puts their finger inside this band design, it's possible they will be left with outlines on their finger's skin that mirror that of the design of the band. The open design may also not feel as comfortable as something that is more solid, especially on the part that the back of the finger rests against.

Hope that information/feedback is helpful. Let me know if you have any questions about the above.