Iona AbbeyBlind

in Architectural Design held by mtwoed
Contest Ended, Winner(s) have been selected.
Description:
A recreation of the cathedral section of Iona Abbey in sufficient detail for preliminary thermal, luminance, and acoustic simulations. The model should be furnished, with materials applied in the fashion found in the interior photo below.

An example of the interior for reference to materiality can be found at: canmore.org.uk/collection/1268473.

Architectural drawings can be found at: canmore.org.uk/event/546182. Links at the bottom of the page under “Related Collection Item(s)” will provide high resolution, zoomable images to make out details.
Wants:
Submissions will be evaluated on their recreation of the subject and simulation preparedness based on accuracy and amount of detail.
Additional Information
Submissions should be made as OBJ files with material properties attached for Solidworks analysis.

Entries

1st Winner
#2 iona by P3N
This is solid model with physical materials applied.
more
Jan 12, 2021 13:57
#1 Iona Abbey by FalconV
Jan 12, 2021 13:55

Discussion

mtwoed

Buyer

Sat, 09 Jan 2021 12:36:00 +0000
Submissions should be made as OBJ files with material properties attached for Solidworks analysis.

mtwoed

Buyer

Sat, 09 Jan 2021 12:32:19 +0000
The final deliverable for the contest are the model files themselves. Snapshots may be used to demonstrate details and accuracy of the submission.
Sat, 09 Jan 2021 11:20:56 +0000
Hi,
You still haven't clarified the deliverable for the contest. It's fine to do the simulations for later on but something still needs to be delivered for the meantime. Would images work? Like snapshots of the final model?

mtwoed

Buyer

Sat, 09 Jan 2021 10:36:42 +0000
Only the cathedral, or church section, itself is to be modelled. None of the further buildings that make up the abbey are required. The model should be of the cathedral in its complete state, not ruins. Reference sources of the Abbey's restoration may be used to complete this task.

mtwoed

Buyer

Sat, 09 Jan 2021 10:23:46 +0000
The end use of the model is for simulations. However, running the simulations themselves will happen at a later date and are not part of this contest.
Sat, 09 Jan 2021 04:23:02 +0000
Following my initial post/question, in terms of the simulations you are looking for:
- thermal simulation: we need a better definition of the deliverable here, as this usually means calculation reports.
- acoustic simulation: this is similar to the above with some minor drawings/visualisation that can be provided as part of the deliverables.
- illumination simulation: similar to above

P3N

Designer

Sat, 09 Jan 2021 01:51:28 +0000
Images that you provided depict Iona prior to restoration. And you want it to be modeled in current state like https://johnrenshawarchitects.co.uk/iona/. Do you want the model of the entire cathedral or only restored parts ?
Fri, 08 Jan 2021 23:20:22 +0000
Can you please better state the deliverables? STL, IGES, OBJ files? If you want materials they will need to attached in a native format such as NX, CATIA, Solidworks, etc...
Fri, 08 Jan 2021 22:13:29 +0000
Interesting and straight-forward project. What type of a deliverable/simulation model are you actually looking to be delivered for you? A BIM IFC model? OBJ file?

Similar Contests on Cad Crowd

Looking for floorplan for "Duplex" Office Building (New Construction)
We've purchased a piece of land and are building office space for two law firms, and are looking at potentially having a "duplex" model where we put two single-story spaces together, with separate entrances. We need some help working through potential floor plan layouts for each side of the duplex. These layouts will help us with our planning process for the site. We're looking for a floorplan design on how we can lay the spaces out in the most flexible way while still having the required spaces/offices that we mention in the attachments/notes. If there is "extra" space in a particular side of the building, we'd love your suggestions on how to fill it.
Pelican Seafood
Expansion of Seafood Market into high end grocery and restaurant.
Storefront design
we need a new design for a existing store front.
Separation Wall, Ceilings and Flooring 3D & Sketch Designs
I wish to have internal drawing designs done that can show visually the installation and fixing details when applying our MgO Corp Board products to Timber and Steel Framing Systems as well as roof battening and applied to masonry walls. I would like the detail to note the processes, material, Rw Acoustic Solution of system combination, Single sheet and Combined sheet FRL's performances on a system and combined system R-Values options. We are competing against James Hardie, Boral, CSR in the building products market. Our product out performs all the above structurally, acoustic, impact and fire. We need to now show this in drawings so Engineers, designers, architects, builders, specifiers xyz can clearly and quickly understand the application and installation methods of our products. Our website is: www.mgoboard.com.au and the following is links to technical information MOST IMPORTANT: The detail has to be to a standard an Engineer will sign off on the drawings!!!!!!
Creative Floor plan for bungalow remodel / 2nd storey addition
Need a simple floor plan - can be in any software or sketch by hand as long as it is to scale. Need Main floor and 2nd floor Looking for creative ideas to fit all the wishlist requirements Blank floor plan with notes attached Wishlist with photos and what I like for inspiration